22 Reviews

Colts Timeless Tattoos

Appleton, Wisconsin
General Info
Visit often to see what we're up to, specials, contests, etc.! Visit our website at www.timelesstattoos.com!
Reviews
Kyle Ofsdahl
14 Jul 2018
REPORT
Convenient location in the mall in the rotunda above the food court. Friendly, professional staff and reasonable pricing - definitely will be my go-to for tattoos in the future.
Erin Jarman
2 Jul 2018
REPORT
Love this place. Saw Adrian told him what I wanted and he ran with it.....awesome
Charlie W
16 Jun 2018
REPORT
I had an industrial done. Piercings are walkin first come first serve. Staff is super friendly. The prices are fair and it was quick clean service!!
Erin Hansen
24 May 2018
REPORT
I'm so happy with the tattoo Nathan did for me. He listened to me and suggested changes that enhanced the design and showed my personality more. He got to know me and what I wanted my tattoo to symbol... Read More
I'm so happy with the tattoo Nathan did for me. He listened to me and suggested changes that enhanced the design and showed my personality more. He got to know me and what I wanted my tattoo to symbolize, before drawing it out. I'm really impressed with his artwork and his attention to detail. I recommend Nathan to everyone. Read Less
B Treml
22 Apr 2018
REPORT
I have always recieved fantastic service and have been treated like family by not one but two tattoo artists. Whether it's your first time or 101 time in under the needle you will always feel comforta... Read More
I have always recieved fantastic service and have been treated like family by not one but two tattoo artists. Whether it's your first time or 101 time in under the needle you will always feel comfortable. If the artist you're looking at to do your piece isn't familiar with the style you want they will help you find someone for you to work with. Price has always been great and they are willing to work with what you have. LORD HAVE MERTZY Read Less
Nicole Miller
3 Apr 2018
REPORT
I went in here thinking I was just going to get a longer bar for my 2 week old navel piercing (because the shop I went to has way too much skin holding the piercing, causing a pressure wound). I met w... Read More
I went in here thinking I was just going to get a longer bar for my 2 week old navel piercing (because the shop I went to has way too much skin holding the piercing, causing a pressure wound). I met with Steven and he said it'd only be ten dollars for him to customly bend a tongue ring (barbell), remove my current jewelry and put in this new one. When we were done, he said not to worry about paying the ten bucks and my mind was blown. Steven was super nice, personalable, made me feel comfortable and was very gentle in the removal and replacement of the jewelry. Way to go Steven - you were great! Read Less
Elizabeth Smith
25 Feb 2018
REPORT
I got my daith pierced by Devin and he was great! He made me feel welcome and made jokes to lighten the mood. Very experienced and great staff to be around!
Kristen Dees
21 Jan 2018
REPORT
Best tattoo shop in Appleton! Truly the friendliest and all around amazing staff and environment! If you need a piercing done I highly recommend Steven! 🀩
Bailey Geurts
4 Dec 2017
REPORT
I’ve only had piercings done here, but Abby is amazing! I would highly recommend her. She is always super friendly and is very good at what she does. I had to get a dermal of mine removed due to it be... Read More
I’ve only had piercings done here, but Abby is amazing! I would highly recommend her. She is always super friendly and is very good at what she does. I had to get a dermal of mine removed due to it being very irritated, Although painful, Abby did everything to help make me as comfortable as possible and it was very quick. Read Less
Addison C.
28 Jul 2017
REPORT
Matt did a couple small pieces on my fingers. While he was reluctant at first they turned out beautiful. I couldn't be happier with professionalism and kindness of the staff. The young woman at the fr... Read More
Matt did a couple small pieces on my fingers. While he was reluctant at first they turned out beautiful. I couldn't be happier with professionalism and kindness of the staff. The young woman at the front desk was especially helpful. Even when calling to inquire about appointment availability they were extremely friendly. I love out of state but my parents live in the area, already planning another tat for my next visit. Thanks again guys. Read Less
Amanda W
10 Jun 2017
REPORT
Had numerous horrible experiences today at other shops Colts saved the day and my piercings are good to go finally!
Colette Krablien
15 May 2017
REPORT
Mothers day tattoos for my daughter and I. The artist who did mine was a really nice person. Not overly chatty. But, the conversation was good. He was relaxed and professional. I absolutely love the c... Read More
Mothers day tattoos for my daughter and I. The artist who did mine was a really nice person. Not overly chatty. But, the conversation was good. He was relaxed and professional. I absolutely love the colors with the butterfly my daughter and I chose. I would definitely recommend going there. I know I will definitely be going back. Thank you so much for doing my timeless tattoo! Read Less
Joyce Marx
7 Mar 2017
REPORT
I decided to get a daith piercing to help with migraines. I was extremely nervous and Abby was wonderful walking me through the entire process. Is recommend her to anyone
Audra W.
13 Feb 2017
REPORT
My sister and I got our tattoos here together recently. Mertzy was our artist and he was great! He was so hilarious and great to talk to and did a phenomenal job with our tattoos. The minimum there is... Read More
My sister and I got our tattoos here together recently. Mertzy was our artist and he was great! He was so hilarious and great to talk to and did a phenomenal job with our tattoos. The minimum there is $60 for tattoos and all their prices are totally reasonable. The place is very clean and neat and all the staff was helpful and nice. Read Less
brianna k
14 Jan 2017
REPORT
The guy that did my nose was really nice to both me and my mom. He was super friendly and I felt really comfortable getting my nose pierced! He explained everything I needed to know and it was overall... Read More
The guy that did my nose was really nice to both me and my mom. He was super friendly and I felt really comfortable getting my nose pierced! He explained everything I needed to know and it was overall a really great experience. Definitely would reccomend! Read Less
TheScarlett33
15 Nov 2016
REPORT
A huge zero if it were possible :/ My daughter turned 18 and ran to get an orbital piercing. This was the nastiest mess I have ever seen due to a piercing. Proper care instructions were not given at t... Read More
A huge zero if it were possible :/ My daughter turned 18 and ran to get an orbital piercing. This was the nastiest mess I have ever seen due to a piercing. Proper care instructions were not given at time of piercing. I had to take her elsewhere to get info on how to heal it properly. What she was told here to do to take care of it was the exact opposite of what we did to heal it. Just in it to take kid's cash. Shameful. Read Less
Payton J.
8 May 2016
REPORT
I went to the mall shop and Abby was my piercer-- she was great! I couldn't have asked for a better experience! I have gotten other piercings before but she still let me know what she was doing, step ... Read More
I went to the mall shop and Abby was my piercer-- she was great! I couldn't have asked for a better experience! I have gotten other piercings before but she still let me know what she was doing, step by step, and educated me on cleaning and aftercare for my piercing. The shop also has an awesome selection of jewelry with fair prices, and all around great service! Read Less
Amanda J.
18 Feb 2016
REPORT
I went to the shop at the mall. Β Great quality tattoo, for a very reasonable price. Β Wouldn't go anywhere else, unless it's the College Ave shop.
Brenda V.
30 Jan 2016
REPORT
I cannot speak in reference to all of the artists, but Jen was awful. My mother and I were walk-ins for small tattoos. I originally was uncertain with my design but decided exactly what I wanted while... Read More
I cannot speak in reference to all of the artists, but Jen was awful. My mother and I were walk-ins for small tattoos. I originally was uncertain with my design but decided exactly what I wanted while my mom got hers done. She stenciled it, forgot a few small lines (which wasn't a big deal, but I wanted them included.) So, she included them into the new stencil and came back to place it. She placed it twice and I was still a bit unsure about placement. I wanted to make sure it was in a spot I was happy with. This was a matter of minutes.. not an eternity which she made it seem like. She was making me very uncomfortable by telling me she was wasting her time and she could tell I didn't know what I wanted. I absolutely wanted that tattoo. But her attitude made me ultimately decide to forget it. I didn't want someone tattooing me angry. Period. She was very nice to us originally. After the first stencil she said her boss was upset with her for taking too long on five minute tattoos. As far as I was concerned.. I decided what I wanted. If I wanted to take five minutes to get the placement right, then I shouldn't be made to feel terrible about doing so. I left furious. She told me she rarely loses her patience and my indecisiveness was pushing her over the edge, or something to that effect. My mother and I were nice as can be to her and in no way deserved to be treated this way. I feel awful that what was supposed to be a nice time together turned into a waste of a day. I see my mom about once a year because of distance, so this was our day together this year. I was shocked with the flip of a switch behavior and will never return. I will tell people to stay away. Read Less
Eve K.
15 Jul 2014
REPORT
Grayson was my artist. He's a super personable guy and is someone who takes all your ideas into consideration. Rates are very reasonable at 120$-150$ given the quality of work produced. Definitely giv... Read More
Grayson was my artist. He's a super personable guy and is someone who takes all your ideas into consideration. Rates are very reasonable at 120$-150$ given the quality of work produced. Definitely give them a shot!EDIT: I went to the Appleton shop on college ave. There are two in Appleton Read Less
tristalynn
19 Jul 2011
REPORT
I'm getting my tattoo done here in September by Jamie. I went with a few friends while they got their tattoo's done and the 2 hours that I sat in there I watched as they checked ID's before they begin... Read More
I'm getting my tattoo done here in September by Jamie. I went with a few friends while they got their tattoo's done and the 2 hours that I sat in there I watched as they checked ID's before they begin the tattoo process. It's a law and a scanned ID must go on the signed paper work before a tattoo or piercing is done. I recommend this Tattoo Parlor to all of my friends and family, the atmosphere is wonderful and the artists are excellent. Read Less
bikersteve9999
20 Jun 2010
REPORT
What a joke this place is. It took forever for someone to come up with a design after I told them exactly what I wanted and they couldn't get it right. I finally went in with pictures of what I wante... Read More
What a joke this place is. It took forever for someone to come up with a design after I told them exactly what I wanted and they couldn't get it right. I finally went in with pictures of what I wanted and photos of other tattoos and told them which parts went where and the drawing he came up with was so lame I couldn't believe my eyes! After about 6 weeks of missed appointments, confusion on the part of the "artist" and complete ineptitude I finally asked for my money back so I could go find a REAL tattoo shop and a real artist. What a bunch of morons! Stay away from this one. I guess that's what I get for going to a shop at the mall. I suppose they can get away with this when their target audience is 18 year old mallrats. Read Less
Photo Gallery
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
Book an Appointment
Online booking unavailable
Please call
(920) 380-2300
4301 W Wisconsin Ave
Appleton Wisconsin 54913
Business Hours
Monday
Mon
10:00AM-21:00PM
Tuesday
Tue
10:00AM-21:00PM
Wednesday
Wed
10:00AM-21:00PM
Thursday
Thu
10:00AM-21:00PM
Friday
Fri
10:00AM-21:00PM
Saturday
Sat
10:00AM-21:00PM
Sunday
Sun
10:00AM-18:00PM
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know

Colts Timeless Tattoos

Appleton, Wisconsin
(22)
4301 W Wisconsin Ave
Appleton Wisconsin 54913
Visit often to see what we're up to, specials, contests, etc.! Visit our website at www.timelesstattoos.com!
Monday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Tuesday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Wednesday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Thursday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Friday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Saturday
10:00AM-21:00PM
Sunday
10:00AM-18:00PM
Kyle Ofsdahl
14 Jul 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Convenient location in the mall in the rotunda above the food court. Friendly, professional staff and reasonable pricing - definitely will be my go-to for tattoos in the future.
Erin Jarman
2 Jul 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Love this place. Saw Adrian told him what I wanted and he ran with it.....awesome
Charlie W
16 Jun 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I had an industrial done. Piercings are walkin first come first serve. Staff is super friendly. The prices are fair and it was quick clean service!!
Erin Hansen
24 May 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I'm so happy with the tattoo Nathan did for me. He listened to me and suggested changes that enhanced the design and showed my personality more. He got to know me and what I wanted my tattoo to symbol... Read More
I'm so happy with the tattoo Nathan did for me. He listened to me and suggested changes that enhanced the design and showed my personality more. He got to know me and what I wanted my tattoo to symbolize, before drawing it out. I'm really impressed with his artwork and his attention to detail. I recommend Nathan to everyone. Read Less
B Treml
22 Apr 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I have always recieved fantastic service and have been treated like family by not one but two tattoo artists. Whether it's your first time or 101 time in under the needle you will always feel comforta... Read More
I have always recieved fantastic service and have been treated like family by not one but two tattoo artists. Whether it's your first time or 101 time in under the needle you will always feel comfortable. If the artist you're looking at to do your piece isn't familiar with the style you want they will help you find someone for you to work with. Price has always been great and they are willing to work with what you have. LORD HAVE MERTZY Read Less
Nicole Miller
3 Apr 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I went in here thinking I was just going to get a longer bar for my 2 week old navel piercing (because the shop I went to has way too much skin holding the piercing, causing a pressure wound). I met w... Read More
I went in here thinking I was just going to get a longer bar for my 2 week old navel piercing (because the shop I went to has way too much skin holding the piercing, causing a pressure wound). I met with Steven and he said it'd only be ten dollars for him to customly bend a tongue ring (barbell), remove my current jewelry and put in this new one. When we were done, he said not to worry about paying the ten bucks and my mind was blown. Steven was super nice, personalable, made me feel comfortable and was very gentle in the removal and replacement of the jewelry. Way to go Steven - you were great! Read Less
Elizabeth Smith
25 Feb 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I got my daith pierced by Devin and he was great! He made me feel welcome and made jokes to lighten the mood. Very experienced and great staff to be around!
Kristen Dees
21 Jan 2018
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Best tattoo shop in Appleton! Truly the friendliest and all around amazing staff and environment! If you need a piercing done I highly recommend Steven! 🀩
Bailey Geurts
4 Dec 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I’ve only had piercings done here, but Abby is amazing! I would highly recommend her. She is always super friendly and is very good at what she does. I had to get a dermal of mine removed due to it be... Read More
I’ve only had piercings done here, but Abby is amazing! I would highly recommend her. She is always super friendly and is very good at what she does. I had to get a dermal of mine removed due to it being very irritated, Although painful, Abby did everything to help make me as comfortable as possible and it was very quick. Read Less
Addison C.
28 Jul 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Matt did a couple small pieces on my fingers. While he was reluctant at first they turned out beautiful. I couldn't be happier with professionalism and kindness of the staff. The young woman at the fr... Read More
Matt did a couple small pieces on my fingers. While he was reluctant at first they turned out beautiful. I couldn't be happier with professionalism and kindness of the staff. The young woman at the front desk was especially helpful. Even when calling to inquire about appointment availability they were extremely friendly. I love out of state but my parents live in the area, already planning another tat for my next visit. Thanks again guys. Read Less
Amanda W
10 Jun 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Had numerous horrible experiences today at other shops Colts saved the day and my piercings are good to go finally!
Colette Krablien
15 May 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Mothers day tattoos for my daughter and I. The artist who did mine was a really nice person. Not overly chatty. But, the conversation was good. He was relaxed and professional. I absolutely love the c... Read More
Mothers day tattoos for my daughter and I. The artist who did mine was a really nice person. Not overly chatty. But, the conversation was good. He was relaxed and professional. I absolutely love the colors with the butterfly my daughter and I chose. I would definitely recommend going there. I know I will definitely be going back. Thank you so much for doing my timeless tattoo! Read Less
Joyce Marx
7 Mar 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I decided to get a daith piercing to help with migraines. I was extremely nervous and Abby was wonderful walking me through the entire process. Is recommend her to anyone
Audra W.
13 Feb 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
My sister and I got our tattoos here together recently. Mertzy was our artist and he was great! He was so hilarious and great to talk to and did a phenomenal job with our tattoos. The minimum there is... Read More
My sister and I got our tattoos here together recently. Mertzy was our artist and he was great! He was so hilarious and great to talk to and did a phenomenal job with our tattoos. The minimum there is $60 for tattoos and all their prices are totally reasonable. The place is very clean and neat and all the staff was helpful and nice. Read Less
brianna k
14 Jan 2017
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
The guy that did my nose was really nice to both me and my mom. He was super friendly and I felt really comfortable getting my nose pierced! He explained everything I needed to know and it was overall... Read More
The guy that did my nose was really nice to both me and my mom. He was super friendly and I felt really comfortable getting my nose pierced! He explained everything I needed to know and it was overall a really great experience. Definitely would reccomend! Read Less
TheScarlett33
15 Nov 2016
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
A huge zero if it were possible :/ My daughter turned 18 and ran to get an orbital piercing. This was the nastiest mess I have ever seen due to a piercing. Proper care instructions were not given at t... Read More
A huge zero if it were possible :/ My daughter turned 18 and ran to get an orbital piercing. This was the nastiest mess I have ever seen due to a piercing. Proper care instructions were not given at time of piercing. I had to take her elsewhere to get info on how to heal it properly. What she was told here to do to take care of it was the exact opposite of what we did to heal it. Just in it to take kid's cash. Shameful. Read Less
Payton J.
8 May 2016
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I went to the mall shop and Abby was my piercer-- she was great! I couldn't have asked for a better experience! I have gotten other piercings before but she still let me know what she was doing, step ... Read More
I went to the mall shop and Abby was my piercer-- she was great! I couldn't have asked for a better experience! I have gotten other piercings before but she still let me know what she was doing, step by step, and educated me on cleaning and aftercare for my piercing. The shop also has an awesome selection of jewelry with fair prices, and all around great service! Read Less
Amanda J.
18 Feb 2016
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I went to the shop at the mall. Β Great quality tattoo, for a very reasonable price. Β Wouldn't go anywhere else, unless it's the College Ave shop.
Brenda V.
30 Jan 2016
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I cannot speak in reference to all of the artists, but Jen was awful. My mother and I were walk-ins for small tattoos. I originally was uncertain with my design but decided exactly what I wanted while... Read More
I cannot speak in reference to all of the artists, but Jen was awful. My mother and I were walk-ins for small tattoos. I originally was uncertain with my design but decided exactly what I wanted while my mom got hers done. She stenciled it, forgot a few small lines (which wasn't a big deal, but I wanted them included.) So, she included them into the new stencil and came back to place it. She placed it twice and I was still a bit unsure about placement. I wanted to make sure it was in a spot I was happy with. This was a matter of minutes.. not an eternity which she made it seem like. She was making me very uncomfortable by telling me she was wasting her time and she could tell I didn't know what I wanted. I absolutely wanted that tattoo. But her attitude made me ultimately decide to forget it. I didn't want someone tattooing me angry. Period. She was very nice to us originally. After the first stencil she said her boss was upset with her for taking too long on five minute tattoos. As far as I was concerned.. I decided what I wanted. If I wanted to take five minutes to get the placement right, then I shouldn't be made to feel terrible about doing so. I left furious. She told me she rarely loses her patience and my indecisiveness was pushing her over the edge, or something to that effect. My mother and I were nice as can be to her and in no way deserved to be treated this way. I feel awful that what was supposed to be a nice time together turned into a waste of a day. I see my mom about once a year because of distance, so this was our day together this year. I was shocked with the flip of a switch behavior and will never return. I will tell people to stay away. Read Less
Eve K.
15 Jul 2014
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
Grayson was my artist. He's a super personable guy and is someone who takes all your ideas into consideration. Rates are very reasonable at 120$-150$ given the quality of work produced. Definitely giv... Read More
Grayson was my artist. He's a super personable guy and is someone who takes all your ideas into consideration. Rates are very reasonable at 120$-150$ given the quality of work produced. Definitely give them a shot!EDIT: I went to the Appleton shop on college ave. There are two in Appleton Read Less
tristalynn
19 Jul 2011
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
I'm getting my tattoo done here in September by Jamie. I went with a few friends while they got their tattoo's done and the 2 hours that I sat in there I watched as they checked ID's before they begin... Read More
I'm getting my tattoo done here in September by Jamie. I went with a few friends while they got their tattoo's done and the 2 hours that I sat in there I watched as they checked ID's before they begin the tattoo process. It's a law and a scanned ID must go on the signed paper work before a tattoo or piercing is done. I recommend this Tattoo Parlor to all of my friends and family, the atmosphere is wonderful and the artists are excellent. Read Less
bikersteve9999
20 Jun 2010
β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜†
REPORT
What a joke this place is. It took forever for someone to come up with a design after I told them exactly what I wanted and they couldn't get it right. I finally went in with pictures of what I wante... Read More
What a joke this place is. It took forever for someone to come up with a design after I told them exactly what I wanted and they couldn't get it right. I finally went in with pictures of what I wanted and photos of other tattoos and told them which parts went where and the drawing he came up with was so lame I couldn't believe my eyes! After about 6 weeks of missed appointments, confusion on the part of the "artist" and complete ineptitude I finally asked for my money back so I could go find a REAL tattoo shop and a real artist. What a bunch of morons! Stay away from this one. I guess that's what I get for going to a shop at the mall. I suppose they can get away with this when their target audience is 18 year old mallrats. Read Less
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know