29 Reviews

Tattoo Tony's Under My Skin

Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey
Reviews
Jennifer P.
7 Dec 2018
REPORT
I got one tattoo there before. And the man at the desk tried to talk me out of it before hand. I insisted, so they did it.The second time I went there was not so easy. The man at the desk said he had ... Read More
I got one tattoo there before. And the man at the desk tried to talk me out of it before hand. I insisted, so they did it.The second time I went there was not so easy. The man at the desk said he had to draw up my idea and when I went back the next day, I guess I insulted him by saying it wasn't exactly what I wanted. There were birds, and flowers and the flowers just looked really big. He said it would take him a day to change it. By that, I just wanted to tattoo and didn't want to bother waiting for him. I went to attractive tattoo on route 36 in Hazlet. They were amazing, ask for Lee. Read Less
Louise Stuart
26 Jun 2018
REPORT
Amazing in every way! With my 50th coming up I decided to cover a 20 year old tat on my lower back with an owl (older and wiser;) It was awkwardly shaped and I knew it would take some work by the arti... Read More
Amazing in every way! With my 50th coming up I decided to cover a 20 year old tat on my lower back with an owl (older and wiser;) It was awkwardly shaped and I knew it would take some work by the artist and compromise by me regarding my vision. Tony really listened and created a piece that was better than I envisioned. I came in nervous and was immediately put at ease by his kindness and professionalism. I knew I was in the right place and in good hands. You only need one session and/or conversation with Tony to know that he is, not only an amazing artist, but an amazing person as well. Read Less
Robert Keir
18 Jun 2018
REPORT
I just got a tattoo there and I love to work that they do I will keep on going back to them for now on the tattoo artist name is Anthony he's a great guy and he knows what he's doing ..........
Monika Humphrey
6 Apr 2018
REPORT
Tony made me very comfortable and reassured me that everything would go fine he was gentle I am honored and privileged to have him do a piercing for me.
Pete Flores
10 Mar 2018
REPORT
Great place, great atmosphere, great artists. Kat did an outstanding job, pain free, and extremely gentle. Will definitely go back.
Chastity Carroll
19 Feb 2018
REPORT
The greatest place the greatest people they're so sweet and professional it's just a great experience when I'm there every time
joey reamer
11 Dec 2017
REPORT
Awesome work. I love this place. Tony s is way better than all the places in Keyport. Much more professional. And alot nicer.
Ethan Werrlein
11 Nov 2017
REPORT
One of New Jerseys finest tattoo shops. The owner has been substantially helping out the community with food and toy drives and has raised over 99k for Autism. Tattoo Tony is truly a caring human bein... Read More
One of New Jerseys finest tattoo shops. The owner has been substantially helping out the community with food and toy drives and has raised over 99k for Autism. Tattoo Tony is truly a caring human being with some incredible artists working for him. Read Less
George Cooper
13 Jul 2017
REPORT
The best group of people you'll ever meet! They are all very respectful and courteous to all! And you are always made to feel like one of the family. And Tony is an amazing artist that understands eve... Read More
The best group of people you'll ever meet! They are all very respectful and courteous to all! And you are always made to feel like one of the family. And Tony is an amazing artist that understands everything and what you are looking for and will never put a tattoo on anyone unless there 100% sure it's what they want! And he has an amazing imagination and great ideas when it comes to designing tattoos just by what you tell him! And has top quality inks and equipment. And a soft touch! I have never walked out feeling any pain or discomfort! I would recommend him to everyone his facility is the most immaculate and well laid out you'll ever find. I even brought my own daughter to him as well!Read Less
Bryan Becze
3 Jul 2017
REPORT
This place is what I have come to think of as the "authentic" tattoo parlor. It's not one of those hipster joints trying to be like Miami Ink. There is a classic ambiance to the place, and Tony's of... Read More
This place is what I have come to think of as the "authentic" tattoo parlor. It's not one of those hipster joints trying to be like Miami Ink. There is a classic ambiance to the place, and Tony's office is filled with some awesome popular culture history. Tony did a custom, solid black piece on my should/trap area. Normally, it would have taken anyone else 3-4 hours, but he had me done in one hour. Not only that, he stood by his work and so do I. Tony and his employees are great and I highly recommend Under My Skin. Read Less
Jenna Eckert
2 Jul 2017
REPORT
Awesome shop!!! Clean, organized and great artist!!! Best shop around. I won't go anywhere else.
Brian Grable
30 Jun 2017
REPORT
Clean shop. There is a diversified group of talented artists that tattoo here. I wouldn't go anywhere else.
Diane Connolly
20 Jun 2017
REPORT
James O'Hanlon is a great tattoo artist. Always go to him. He did this tattoo for my niece when her father passed away.
Ginger Arthur
20 Jun 2017
REPORT
Every time I have work done, I walk away feeling incredibly happy with what I had done. Tony comes up with the best ideas and the most fantastic artwork! I have never, in all the years he has tattoo... Read More
Every time I have work done, I walk away feeling incredibly happy with what I had done. Tony comes up with the best ideas and the most fantastic artwork! I have never, in all the years he has tattooed me, had a bad experience or didn't like my artwork. Tony and his employees are the best, and I can't even imagine ever going someplace else. You guys ROCK! Read Less
Grace Harkness-Todd
13 Jun 2017
REPORT
Awesome place to get a tattoo. Artists are amazing. My son got his first tattoo the other day and his experience was great. They made him feel comfortable. Besides that it came out amazing. Thanks Mic... Read More
Awesome place to get a tattoo. Artists are amazing. My son got his first tattoo the other day and his experience was great. They made him feel comfortable. Besides that it came out amazing. Thanks Michele and Tony. We love our tats Read Less
Michael Marella
9 Jun 2017
REPORT
Both my parents have been coming here for over 20 years to get their tattoos, I would be second generation. Everyone was awesome, prices are more then fair and James did an awesome ass job on my tatt... Read More
Both my parents have been coming here for over 20 years to get their tattoos, I would be second generation. Everyone was awesome, prices are more then fair and James did an awesome ass job on my tattoo. I Could not be happier. Can't wait to draw up my next one Read Less
Taylor K.
20 May 2017
REPORT
I came in to get a simple tattoo. The artist said it was too detailed for him to do, regardless of price. I paid $100 for an absolute garbage 2 inch rose.
Enzo LaRocca
5 May 2017
REPORT
When you visit Under My Skin Tattoo Studio, you'll find Tony is one of the best humble & skilled guys to know, the brand hosts live events & charities throughout the year, his studio is designed to b... Read More
When you visit Under My Skin Tattoo Studio, you'll find Tony is one of the best humble & skilled guys to know, the brand hosts live events & charities throughout the year, his studio is designed to be visually stunning, his staff are always a blend of different talents, it's more than a day of gettin ink, its an experience! Read Less
Robert Bolognese
18 Apr 2017
REPORT
Horrible , went in for a walk in , simple tattoo . Walked out with a abomination on my hand . Supposed to be a skull . Total abortion . And the artist had the nerve to trash talk the owner of anoth... Read More
Horrible , went in for a walk in , simple tattoo . Walked out with a abomination on my hand . Supposed to be a skull . Total abortion . And the artist had the nerve to trash talk the owner of another shop . Saying the owner thinks he's a better artist then he is . Wrong . He's the best artist on the East coast and the most humble and nicest person you could ever meet . And that artist is the owner of Teddy bear ink. . You want the best go to the best , mortified at what under my skin put on my body . And repulsed at the artist( so called) for putting down other artists purely out of jealousy and the threat of the competitor for clearly doing way better work . Having ppl that tattoo that bad reflects on the whole shop . Never again. Just keeping it real.Read Less
Michelle Ary
17 Apr 2017
REPORT
@[1621277285:Chris Mirro] is amazing!!! I gave him an idea and a few photos of what I was looking for and he came up with a beautiful masterpiece. Completely in love with the design and shading. Serio... Read More
@[1621277285:Chris Mirro] is amazing!!! I gave him an idea and a few photos of what I was looking for and he came up with a beautiful masterpiece. Completely in love with the design and shading. Seriously godlike for this flawless work of art ���. Even designed it to compliment my shape and assets �. Definitely will be going back for more of his art. Thank you so much!!! Read Less
Chris Gaul
22 Mar 2017
REPORT
I only gave it a 1 cause of the customer service. I went to get an estimate on a tattoo that I wanted but still in the waiting room for a half an hour waiting for somebody to ask me if I needed help. ... Read More
I only gave it a 1 cause of the customer service. I went to get an estimate on a tattoo that I wanted but still in the waiting room for a half an hour waiting for somebody to ask me if I needed help. Was excited to talk to someone about finishing my Hobbit theme sleeve and liked James fantasy art tattoo's! Ive seen work out of the shop and it wad awesome but missed an opportunity! Read Less
Cynthia Homa
10 Mar 2017
REPORT
Michele is there so that makes it five stars right off the bat. Beyond that, everyone in the shop was really cool. No egos there. Clean, friendly and an overall great experience!
Paula Sorrentino
10 Mar 2017
REPORT
I wouldn't go anywhere else to get my tattoos.. Great prices and Amazing Artists
Lisa Hansen
8 Mar 2017
REPORT
Hands down, the best place I've been. Tony did a cover up for me and it came out amazing. I've had several tattoos done by other shops and never again. Tony is now fixing all of my tattoos. I will... Read More
Hands down, the best place I've been. Tony did a cover up for me and it came out amazing. I've had several tattoos done by other shops and never again. Tony is now fixing all of my tattoos. I will trust only Tony's place - under my skin is professional, creative, and a people person with outstanding customer service and prices are extremely reasonable. I loved my experience. � Read Less
Celeste T.
14 Apr 2015
REPORT
Had my 1st tattoo done by Matt - was an awesome experience.   He was great and had a light touch- art work was great,  made me feel very comfortable and at ease.  I would recommend anyone in the shop ... Read More
Had my 1st tattoo done by Matt - was an awesome experience.   He was great and had a light touch- art work was great,  made me feel very comfortable and at ease.  I would recommend anyone in the shop because all the work looks good.  Definitely worth the trip to get ink there!Thank you! Looking forward to my next tattoo! ** check them out ! Read Less
Gen R.
15 Jan 2015
REPORT
Amazing artists and beautiful pieces coming outta this shop! Each time I've been in a chair there I've left delighted with my ink!
LosAngeles G.
30 Oct 2014
REPORT
Excellent work, great prices, and you couldn't ask for better people to trust they'll do exactly what you want and more. Tattoo Tony and his staff are the only people I'll go to for tattoo work.
Nicole C.
25 Sep 2014
REPORT
- nice work and exactly what I wanted I was more than happy with the work I got done. I got a rose and a clock it's honestly so pretty and it was my first tattoo so he explained everything to me .. Af... Read More
- nice work and exactly what I wanted I was more than happy with the work I got done. I got a rose and a clock it's honestly so pretty and it was my first tattoo so he explained everything to me .. After care, peeling, ECT. and amazing artists all around but Tony did my tattoo! He's great! Will defiantly be back in the future . I recommend :) Read Less
Jim P.
26 Sep 2013
REPORT
Incredible tattoo shop. All are true ARTISTS. Matt Murphy was amazing. He created exactly what I wanted. My awesome steampunk Cheshire Cat. Highly recommend him. Tattoo Tony helped me out with a cover... Read More
Incredible tattoo shop. All are true ARTISTS. Matt Murphy was amazing. He created exactly what I wanted. My awesome steampunk Cheshire Cat. Highly recommend him. Tattoo Tony helped me out with a cover up. My sick smiling fish now covers up what I needed home.   You would never know it was a coverup. Read Less
Photo Gallery
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
  • Business's Photo
Book an Appointment
Online booking unavailable
Please call
(732) 872-4092
73 Memorial Parkway
Atlantic Highlands New Jersey 7716
Business Hours
Monday
Mon
12:00PM-22:00PM
Tuesday
Tue
12:00PM-22:00PM
Wednesday
Wed
12:00PM-22:00PM
Thursday
Thu
12:00PM-22:00PM
Friday
Fri
12:00PM-22:00PM
Saturday
Sat
12:00PM-22:00PM
Sunday
Sun
12:00PM-17:00PM
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know

Tattoo Tony's Under My Skin

Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey
(29)
73 Memorial Parkway
Atlantic Highlands New Jersey 7716
Monday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Tuesday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Wednesday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Thursday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Friday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Saturday
12:00PM-22:00PM
Sunday
12:00PM-17:00PM
Jennifer P.
7 Dec 2018
REPORT
I got one tattoo there before. And the man at the desk tried to talk me out of it before hand. I insisted, so they did it.The second time I went there was not so easy. The man at the desk said he had ... Read More
I got one tattoo there before. And the man at the desk tried to talk me out of it before hand. I insisted, so they did it.The second time I went there was not so easy. The man at the desk said he had to draw up my idea and when I went back the next day, I guess I insulted him by saying it wasn't exactly what I wanted. There were birds, and flowers and the flowers just looked really big. He said it would take him a day to change it. By that, I just wanted to tattoo and didn't want to bother waiting for him. I went to attractive tattoo on route 36 in Hazlet. They were amazing, ask for Lee. Read Less
Louise Stuart
26 Jun 2018
REPORT
Amazing in every way! With my 50th coming up I decided to cover a 20 year old tat on my lower back with an owl (older and wiser;) It was awkwardly shaped and I knew it would take some work by the arti... Read More
Amazing in every way! With my 50th coming up I decided to cover a 20 year old tat on my lower back with an owl (older and wiser;) It was awkwardly shaped and I knew it would take some work by the artist and compromise by me regarding my vision. Tony really listened and created a piece that was better than I envisioned. I came in nervous and was immediately put at ease by his kindness and professionalism. I knew I was in the right place and in good hands. You only need one session and/or conversation with Tony to know that he is, not only an amazing artist, but an amazing person as well. Read Less
Robert Keir
18 Jun 2018
REPORT
I just got a tattoo there and I love to work that they do I will keep on going back to them for now on the tattoo artist name is Anthony he's a great guy and he knows what he's doing ..........
Monika Humphrey
6 Apr 2018
REPORT
Tony made me very comfortable and reassured me that everything would go fine he was gentle I am honored and privileged to have him do a piercing for me.
Pete Flores
10 Mar 2018
REPORT
Great place, great atmosphere, great artists. Kat did an outstanding job, pain free, and extremely gentle. Will definitely go back.
Chastity Carroll
19 Feb 2018
REPORT
The greatest place the greatest people they're so sweet and professional it's just a great experience when I'm there every time
joey reamer
11 Dec 2017
REPORT
Awesome work. I love this place. Tony s is way better than all the places in Keyport. Much more professional. And alot nicer.
Ethan Werrlein
11 Nov 2017
REPORT
One of New Jerseys finest tattoo shops. The owner has been substantially helping out the community with food and toy drives and has raised over 99k for Autism. Tattoo Tony is truly a caring human bein... Read More
One of New Jerseys finest tattoo shops. The owner has been substantially helping out the community with food and toy drives and has raised over 99k for Autism. Tattoo Tony is truly a caring human being with some incredible artists working for him. Read Less
George Cooper
13 Jul 2017
REPORT
The best group of people you'll ever meet! They are all very respectful and courteous to all! And you are always made to feel like one of the family. And Tony is an amazing artist that understands eve... Read More
The best group of people you'll ever meet! They are all very respectful and courteous to all! And you are always made to feel like one of the family. And Tony is an amazing artist that understands everything and what you are looking for and will never put a tattoo on anyone unless there 100% sure it's what they want! And he has an amazing imagination and great ideas when it comes to designing tattoos just by what you tell him! And has top quality inks and equipment. And a soft touch! I have never walked out feeling any pain or discomfort! I would recommend him to everyone his facility is the most immaculate and well laid out you'll ever find. I even brought my own daughter to him as well!Read Less
Bryan Becze
3 Jul 2017
REPORT
This place is what I have come to think of as the "authentic" tattoo parlor. It's not one of those hipster joints trying to be like Miami Ink. There is a classic ambiance to the place, and Tony's of... Read More
This place is what I have come to think of as the "authentic" tattoo parlor. It's not one of those hipster joints trying to be like Miami Ink. There is a classic ambiance to the place, and Tony's office is filled with some awesome popular culture history. Tony did a custom, solid black piece on my should/trap area. Normally, it would have taken anyone else 3-4 hours, but he had me done in one hour. Not only that, he stood by his work and so do I. Tony and his employees are great and I highly recommend Under My Skin. Read Less
Jenna Eckert
2 Jul 2017
REPORT
Awesome shop!!! Clean, organized and great artist!!! Best shop around. I won't go anywhere else.
Brian Grable
30 Jun 2017
REPORT
Clean shop. There is a diversified group of talented artists that tattoo here. I wouldn't go anywhere else.
Diane Connolly
20 Jun 2017
REPORT
James O'Hanlon is a great tattoo artist. Always go to him. He did this tattoo for my niece when her father passed away.
Ginger Arthur
20 Jun 2017
REPORT
Every time I have work done, I walk away feeling incredibly happy with what I had done. Tony comes up with the best ideas and the most fantastic artwork! I have never, in all the years he has tattoo... Read More
Every time I have work done, I walk away feeling incredibly happy with what I had done. Tony comes up with the best ideas and the most fantastic artwork! I have never, in all the years he has tattooed me, had a bad experience or didn't like my artwork. Tony and his employees are the best, and I can't even imagine ever going someplace else. You guys ROCK! Read Less
Grace Harkness-Todd
13 Jun 2017
REPORT
Awesome place to get a tattoo. Artists are amazing. My son got his first tattoo the other day and his experience was great. They made him feel comfortable. Besides that it came out amazing. Thanks Mic... Read More
Awesome place to get a tattoo. Artists are amazing. My son got his first tattoo the other day and his experience was great. They made him feel comfortable. Besides that it came out amazing. Thanks Michele and Tony. We love our tats Read Less
Michael Marella
9 Jun 2017
REPORT
Both my parents have been coming here for over 20 years to get their tattoos, I would be second generation. Everyone was awesome, prices are more then fair and James did an awesome ass job on my tatt... Read More
Both my parents have been coming here for over 20 years to get their tattoos, I would be second generation. Everyone was awesome, prices are more then fair and James did an awesome ass job on my tattoo. I Could not be happier. Can't wait to draw up my next one Read Less
Taylor K.
20 May 2017
REPORT
I came in to get a simple tattoo. The artist said it was too detailed for him to do, regardless of price. I paid $100 for an absolute garbage 2 inch rose.
Enzo LaRocca
5 May 2017
REPORT
When you visit Under My Skin Tattoo Studio, you'll find Tony is one of the best humble & skilled guys to know, the brand hosts live events & charities throughout the year, his studio is designed to b... Read More
When you visit Under My Skin Tattoo Studio, you'll find Tony is one of the best humble & skilled guys to know, the brand hosts live events & charities throughout the year, his studio is designed to be visually stunning, his staff are always a blend of different talents, it's more than a day of gettin ink, its an experience! Read Less
Robert Bolognese
18 Apr 2017
REPORT
Horrible , went in for a walk in , simple tattoo . Walked out with a abomination on my hand . Supposed to be a skull . Total abortion . And the artist had the nerve to trash talk the owner of anoth... Read More
Horrible , went in for a walk in , simple tattoo . Walked out with a abomination on my hand . Supposed to be a skull . Total abortion . And the artist had the nerve to trash talk the owner of another shop . Saying the owner thinks he's a better artist then he is . Wrong . He's the best artist on the East coast and the most humble and nicest person you could ever meet . And that artist is the owner of Teddy bear ink. . You want the best go to the best , mortified at what under my skin put on my body . And repulsed at the artist( so called) for putting down other artists purely out of jealousy and the threat of the competitor for clearly doing way better work . Having ppl that tattoo that bad reflects on the whole shop . Never again. Just keeping it real.Read Less
Michelle Ary
17 Apr 2017
REPORT
@[1621277285:Chris Mirro] is amazing!!! I gave him an idea and a few photos of what I was looking for and he came up with a beautiful masterpiece. Completely in love with the design and shading. Serio... Read More
@[1621277285:Chris Mirro] is amazing!!! I gave him an idea and a few photos of what I was looking for and he came up with a beautiful masterpiece. Completely in love with the design and shading. Seriously godlike for this flawless work of art ���. Even designed it to compliment my shape and assets �. Definitely will be going back for more of his art. Thank you so much!!! Read Less
Chris Gaul
22 Mar 2017
REPORT
I only gave it a 1 cause of the customer service. I went to get an estimate on a tattoo that I wanted but still in the waiting room for a half an hour waiting for somebody to ask me if I needed help. ... Read More
I only gave it a 1 cause of the customer service. I went to get an estimate on a tattoo that I wanted but still in the waiting room for a half an hour waiting for somebody to ask me if I needed help. Was excited to talk to someone about finishing my Hobbit theme sleeve and liked James fantasy art tattoo's! Ive seen work out of the shop and it wad awesome but missed an opportunity! Read Less
Cynthia Homa
10 Mar 2017
REPORT
Michele is there so that makes it five stars right off the bat. Beyond that, everyone in the shop was really cool. No egos there. Clean, friendly and an overall great experience!
Paula Sorrentino
10 Mar 2017
REPORT
I wouldn't go anywhere else to get my tattoos.. Great prices and Amazing Artists
Lisa Hansen
8 Mar 2017
REPORT
Hands down, the best place I've been. Tony did a cover up for me and it came out amazing. I've had several tattoos done by other shops and never again. Tony is now fixing all of my tattoos. I will... Read More
Hands down, the best place I've been. Tony did a cover up for me and it came out amazing. I've had several tattoos done by other shops and never again. Tony is now fixing all of my tattoos. I will trust only Tony's place - under my skin is professional, creative, and a people person with outstanding customer service and prices are extremely reasonable. I loved my experience. � Read Less
Celeste T.
14 Apr 2015
REPORT
Had my 1st tattoo done by Matt - was an awesome experience.   He was great and had a light touch- art work was great,  made me feel very comfortable and at ease.  I would recommend anyone in the shop ... Read More
Had my 1st tattoo done by Matt - was an awesome experience.   He was great and had a light touch- art work was great,  made me feel very comfortable and at ease.  I would recommend anyone in the shop because all the work looks good.  Definitely worth the trip to get ink there!Thank you! Looking forward to my next tattoo! ** check them out ! Read Less
Gen R.
15 Jan 2015
REPORT
Amazing artists and beautiful pieces coming outta this shop! Each time I've been in a chair there I've left delighted with my ink!
LosAngeles G.
30 Oct 2014
REPORT
Excellent work, great prices, and you couldn't ask for better people to trust they'll do exactly what you want and more. Tattoo Tony and his staff are the only people I'll go to for tattoo work.
Nicole C.
25 Sep 2014
REPORT
- nice work and exactly what I wanted I was more than happy with the work I got done. I got a rose and a clock it's honestly so pretty and it was my first tattoo so he explained everything to me .. Af... Read More
- nice work and exactly what I wanted I was more than happy with the work I got done. I got a rose and a clock it's honestly so pretty and it was my first tattoo so he explained everything to me .. After care, peeling, ECT. and amazing artists all around but Tony did my tattoo! He's great! Will defiantly be back in the future . I recommend :) Read Less
Jim P.
26 Sep 2013
REPORT
Incredible tattoo shop. All are true ARTISTS. Matt Murphy was amazing. He created exactly what I wanted. My awesome steampunk Cheshire Cat. Highly recommend him. Tattoo Tony helped me out with a cover... Read More
Incredible tattoo shop. All are true ARTISTS. Matt Murphy was amazing. He created exactly what I wanted. My awesome steampunk Cheshire Cat. Highly recommend him. Tattoo Tony helped me out with a cover up. My sick smiling fish now covers up what I needed home.   You would never know it was a coverup. Read Less
Is this your business?
CLAIM IT HERE
Incorrect information? Let us know